amathela: (farscape: john/aeryn)
Be cool, Gail. Be cool. ([personal profile] amathela) wrote2007-11-19 11:17 am

You can't go home again

When first returning home after inadvertently being stranded on another galaxy, I think we've all learned two important lessons:

1) Earth is not real. (Aliens, man. Always play with their minds.)

2) The hot alien space babe you brought with you? Totally is.

EDIT: Corollary 2a) The hot alien space babe likes beer.

Also, as annoying as having a fic Jossed can be, the opposite also holds true. It's always interesting when, instead of being contradicted by canon, a fic (or fic idea) can be so specifically supported by it that it renders the fic essentially useless. Like when, in season three of SGA, everything I was trying to do with As I Say was pretty much summed up in one line by John: "But then I would be the man, and who would I rage against?" On one hand, it's gratifying to know that my take on the character was spot on; that, two years before he comes to that revelation, I got it, and I got him. But on the other ... had I seen that episode at the time, I may never have written the fic, because what would be the point? Or like when I planned to write a Gilmore Girls fic where Luke helps Lorelai pick out the jeep when she first buys it - and then I watched It's Just Like Riding A Bike, where he does exactly that, only eight years later. My Luke-and-Lorelai picking out a car fic became totally canon, and I was left with nothing to write. So. Interesting, and definitely satisfying to know that you've got a great handle on the show/character, but a drawback to writing in open canons that isn't often explored.
ext_2410: (Default)

[identity profile] kimberlyfdr.livejournal.com 2007-11-19 01:51 am (UTC)(link)
SGA is great at making various fanfic ideas canon.

--Random fly-by comment--
ext_7442: (Default)

[identity profile] amathela.livejournal.com 2007-11-19 02:55 am (UTC)(link)
Yeah, SGA relies pretty heavily on tropes, as does a lot of fic, so I can see that happening pretty often.